If the other driver caused the accident, you shouldn't be the one paying a deductible. Here's how it actually works.
One of the first questions after a collision is whether you'll have to pay your deductible. The answer depends on who was at fault and which insurance company the claim is filed with — and the choice you make in the first few days can cost or save you hundreds of dollars.
A deductible is the portion of a covered loss you pay before your own insurance pays the rest. It only applies when you file a claim under your own collision coverage (a first-party claim). If the claim is filed against the at-fault driver's insurance (a third-party claim), there is no deductible — the other driver's liability coverage pays the full amount of the damage.
Which route is better depends on how clear liability is, how fast you need the car back and whether you have rental coverage. We review this with you before any claim is opened.
California uses comparative negligence. If you were found 20% at fault, the other driver's insurer pays 80% of your damages on a third-party claim, and you'd recover 80% of your deductible through subrogation on a first-party claim. Fault determinations can be disputed with evidence — photos, witness statements and the police report.
If the at-fault driver can't be identified or has no insurance, your options are collision coverage (with your deductible) or uninsured motorist property damage (UMPD), which in California typically carries a $3,500 limit and its own deductible. A police report is required for hit-and-run claims — file it as soon as possible.
You may see shops advertising that they'll "waive" or "pay" your deductible. In California, absorbing a deductible without disclosing it to the insurer is insurance fraud, and it usually means the repair is being cut short somewhere. Our Deductible Assistance Program works differently: we make sure the claim is filed against the right carrier so the deductible never applies, we document fault so subrogation recovers it when you did pay, and we check your policy for provisions like collision deductible waiver that many drivers don't know they have. Same result — you keep the money — without the risk.
Before you open a claim, we look at the facts and tell you which route keeps the deductible off your side. We then handle the communication with the insurer, document the loss properly and track the subrogation so your deductible refund doesn't fall through the cracks.
Talk to us before you open a claim. Five minutes now can keep the deductible off your side entirely.
What California insurers owe you when they total your car — and how to push back on a lowball valuation.
Your car lost value the moment it was hit — even after a perfect repair. Here's how to claim that loss.
Your deductible shouldn't decide whether your car gets repaired properly. Here's how we help.
You may be entitled to a replacement vehicle for the entire repair period — if the claim is set up correctly.
Your insurer can recommend a shop. They cannot require one. Here's the law and how to use it.