Insurance Claim Guide

    Your Right to Choose a Body Shop in California

    Your insurer can recommend a shop. They cannot require one. Here's the law and how to use it.

    After a claim is opened, many drivers hear some version of "you need to take it to one of our approved shops." In California that is not true. Insurance Code section 758.5 gives you the right to have your vehicle repaired at the shop of your choice, and the insurer must honor that choice.

    What California Insurance Code 758.5 says

    • An insurer may not require that a vehicle be repaired at a specific shop
    • Once you've chosen a shop, the insurer may not suggest or recommend a different one unless you ask
    • The insurer must tell you in writing that you have the right to choose your repair shop
    • If you use the insurer's recommended shop, the insurer is responsible for the quality of that repair

    Why insurers steer to "preferred" shops

    Direct repair program (DRP) shops agree to the insurer's pricing, labor rates and parts choices in exchange for referrals. That relationship can mean aftermarket or used parts, capped labor times and pressure to close the file quickly. It doesn't make every DRP shop bad, but it means the shop's first customer is the insurance company, not you.

    What steering sounds like — and how to respond

    • "We can't guarantee the repair if you go somewhere else." — The insurer's obligation is to pay for a proper repair regardless of shop; the shop provides the warranty.
    • "Your claim will take longer at another shop." — Timelines depend on the adjuster's responsiveness, not the shop's DRP status.
    • "That shop charges more than we pay." — The insurer must pay the reasonable cost of repair in your market; disputes are handled through supplements, not by moving your car.
    • "You'll have to pay the difference." — Only if you request upgrades beyond restoring the vehicle to pre-loss condition.

    What to do if the insurer refuses your shop

    • State in writing that you are exercising your right under Insurance Code 758.5
    • Ask for the insurer's written acknowledgment of your shop choice
    • Have the shop submit its estimate and supplements directly to the adjuster
    • If the insurer continues to refuse or delay, file a complaint with the California Department of Insurance

    How Grozah Auto Lab helps

    We are an independent, certified body shop that works for the vehicle owner — not a DRP. We submit estimates and supplements directly to the adjuster, document hidden damage and negotiate parts and procedures so the vehicle is repaired to manufacturer standards. If the insurer pushes back on your choice, we handle that conversation.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Being pushed toward a "preferred" shop?

    Send us the claim details. We'll confirm your rights in writing and take over the conversation with the adjuster.

    Call (424) 474-3300